Evaluating a local government Council budget in Nigeria goes beyond checking if money was spent. You need to check if it was planned legally, allocated fairly, spent transparently, and delivered results for residents.
Here are the main criteria used by auditors, civil society, legislators, and researchers:
1. Legal and Policy Compliance
Constitutional basis: Does it comply with Section 7 and Section 162 of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) on local government autonomy, joint account, and functions in the Fourth Schedule?
State laws: Does it follow the State Local Government Law, Financial Memoranda, and State Fiscal Responsibility Law?
Approval process: Was it passed by the Legislative Council, signed by the Chairman, and published before implementation?
Procurement compliance: Were contracts awarded under the Public Procurement Act / State Procurement Law, with tendering and due process?
2. Revenue Realism and Credibility
Revenue forecast accuracy: How close were projected Internally Generated Revenue (IGR), FAAC allocation, VAT, grants, and loans to actual receipts?
IGR effort: Is the Council over-dependent on FAAC, or is it growing IGR from rates, tenement rates, markets, motor parks, licences, and fees?
Budget credibility: Compare approved budget vs. actual revenue and expenditure. A variance above 15-20% consistently suggests poor planning or padding.
3. Allocation and Prioritization
Alignment with needs: Does spending match the Council’s development plan, ward needs, and statutory functions like primary health, primary education support, rural roads, water, sanitation, and markets?
Recurrent vs. Capital ratio: In Nigeria, many Councils spend 80-90% on salaries and overheads. A healthy budget should protect a meaningful share for capital projects.
Equity: Are projects spread fairly across wards, not concentrated in the Chairman’s ward or headquarters?
Pro-poor focus: What share goes to basic services that affect women, youth, traders, farmers, and persons with disabilities?
4. Execution and Efficiency
Budget execution rate: % of approved capital budget actually spent and % of projects completed. Low execution often means abandoned projects.
Timeliness: Were projects completed on schedule and within approved cost? Check for cost overruns and variation orders.
Value for money: Economy (lowest reasonable cost), Efficiency (output per naira), and Effectiveness (did it solve the problem?).
Payroll integrity: Is there ghost-worker control, BVN verification, and a clean nominal roll?
5. Transparency and Participation
Public participation: Were community leaders, CDAs, traditional rulers, women groups, and youth consulted before the budget was drafted?
Openness: Is the approved budget, quarterly reports, and audited statements published on notice boards, radio, or online?
Access to information: Can citizens get project details, contractor names, and costs on request under the Freedom of Information Act?
6. Accountability and Audit
Internal controls: Are there functional Internal Audit, Finance and General Purpose Committee, and Legislative oversight?
External audit: What did the State Auditor-General for Local Governments find? Look for unretired advances, unaccounted cash, and extra-budgetary spending.
Debt and liabilities: Did the Council take loans without approval? Are pension arrears, contractor debts, and staff salary arrears growing?
Asset management: Is there an asset register for vehicles, buildings, and equipment? Are assets maintained or abandoned?
7. Outcomes and Service Delivery Impact
This is the most important test: money spent is not the same as results delivered.
Outputs: How many boreholes, PHCs renovated, classrooms built, roads graded, drains cleared?
Outcomes: Did school enrolment, immunization coverage, access to clean water, or market revenue improve?
Sustainability: Are completed projects functional 1-2 years later, with maintenance budget and community ownership?
Citizen satisfaction: What do residents say in town halls, scorecards, or social audits?
A simple framework to use
You can score each Council budget on 5 questions:
Was it legal? Approved, published, and procured properly
Was it realistic? Revenue forecasts matched reality
Was it fair? Spending reached all wards and basic services
Was it well spent? High execution, low waste, completed projects
Did it change lives? Measurable improvement in services
Next time your local government chair starts claiming that he or she delivered, remember to pullout this post and confront him or her using the very clear criteria and questions in this AI generated post.
Multilingualism and cultural pluralism have received considerable scholarly and policy attention in countries such as the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Belgium, and France because of their implications for national integration, identity preservation, and educational development. In many African countries, however, including Nigeria, these issues have often received only superficial attention despite their enormous significance for social cohesion, equity, and curriculum development.
Nigeria is one of the most culturally and linguistically diverse countries in the world, with over 250 ethnic groups and more than 500 languages. Such diversity presents both opportunities and challenges for education policy and curriculum development. While diversity can enrich learning and strengthen cultural identity, it can also create tensions relating to language policy, representation, access, and national integration.
This paper examines the relationship between multilingualism, cultural pluralism, and curriculum development in Nigerian basic education. It explores the conceptual foundations of multiculturalism and cultural pluralism, analyses their implications for curriculum development, and discusses the advantages, disadvantages, and threats associated with multilingual and culturally plural educational systems. The paper further examines how power relations, linguistic dominance, and educational policy shape curriculum choices in Nigeria and concludes with recommendations for a more inclusive and equitable curriculum framework. The writing of this paper is informed by concerns for equity, respect for language rights and the imperative for culturally responsive pedagogy. A related motivation was the need to broaden the rhetoric on curriculum decolonisation to include recognising the dangers in the subtle colonisation of speakers of minority languages in multilingual African countries such as Nigeria by speakers of dominant languages in these same countries. Implicit in the above is the invitation to the reader that colonisation is colonisation. Denying a speaker of a minority language education in his/her language is thus a measure that could lead to exclusion. Given the vital link between language and indigenous knowledge systems, such an exclusion could also lead to major losses in indigenous knowledge systems for speakers of such languages
Keywords: Multilingualism, cultural pluralism, curriculum development, language policy, minority languages, multicultural education, Nigeria.
Conceptual Clarifications
Multiculturalism and Cultural Pluralism
Multiculturalism refers to the coexistence of multiple cultural groups within a society. It is commonly associated with policies that recognize cultural diversity and encourage the inclusion of different cultural traditions within national life. Multicultural societies may contain dominant and minority cultures of varying demographic and political strength.
Cultural pluralism, on the other hand, refers to a situation in which diverse cultural groups are not only allowed to exist but are also encouraged to preserve and develop their unique identities, languages, traditions, and values. Unlike monocultural systems that encourage assimilation into a dominant culture, cultural pluralism promotes integration without cultural absorption.
The distinction between multiculturalism and cultural pluralism is significant. Multiculturalism may simply describe the presence of multiple cultures, whereas cultural pluralism implies deliberate policies aimed at protecting minority identities and ensuring equitable representation.
Linguicism and Linguistic Imperialism
The concept of linguicism, introduced by Tove Skutnabb-Kangas, refers to discrimination based on language. It describes ideological and structural processes that privilege certain languages while marginalizing others.
Closely related is the idea of linguistic imperialism, developed by Robert Phillipson, which explains how dominant languages expand through political, educational, and economic power structures. In multilingual societies such as Nigeria, language choices in education often reflect broader struggles over power, identity, and cultural dominance.
The privileging of major languages over minority languages in schools can therefore become a mechanism for reinforcing social inequalities and weakening minority cultures.
Curriculum Development as a Political and Cultural Process
Curriculum development is often presented as a technical or pedagogical process involving the selection of learning content, teaching methods, and evaluation procedures. However, curriculum development is also deeply political and ideological because it involves decisions about:
what knowledge is valuable;
whose culture is represented;
which languages are promoted;
which histories are remembered;
and what kind of society education seeks to create.
Education is not culturally neutral. Beyond transmitting knowledge and skills, it also functions as a mechanism for cultural transmission, identity formation, and social reproduction.
Scholars such as Pierre Bourdieu and Michael Young argue that curriculum can become an instrument for reproducing dominant cultural values while marginalizing less powerful groups. In multicultural societies, curriculum development therefore reflects existing power relations and ideological preferences This is especially evident in subjects such as language, history, social studies, religion, literature and civic education. These subjects often privilege dominant cultural narratives while underrepresenting minority perspectives.
Multilingualism and Cultural Pluralism in Nigeria
Nigeria’s educational system operates within a highly multilingual and multicultural environment. The country’s language policy recognizes English as the official language and identifies Hausa, Igbo, and Yoruba as the three major Nigerian languages. Numerous other indigenous languages are recognized as mother tongues, although many are not adequately supported within formal education.
This arrangement has generated significant educational and sociopolitical tensions.
For example, children from minority linguistic backgrounds frequently experience what may be described as a “multiple language burden.” A child from a minority ethnic group living outside his or her ancestral community may be required to learn:
the local dominant language;
one of the three major Nigerian languages;
and English.
This creates unequal linguistic demands compared to children from dominant linguistic groups.
The emphasis on the three major languages also creates concerns about:
linguistic marginalization;
unequal resource allocation;
cultural domination;
and the gradual disappearance of minority languages.
The latter concern, that of a concern with the phenomenon of language disappearance, sometimes described as glottophagy, becomes when smaller languages are gradually abandoned due to pressure from dominant languages and cultures.
Models of Cultural Pluralism
The literature identifies several models of cultural pluralism:
Cooperative Model -Different cultural groups collaborate harmoniously while maintaining their identities.
Conflict Model – Cultural groups compete for recognition, influence, and resources, often generating tension.
Coercive Model – Dominant groups compel minority groups to adopt dominant cultural norms; and
Domination Model – Powerful groups impose their culture through institutions such as schools, media, and government policies (Young, 1979; Phillipson, 1997)
In reality, most societies display elements of several models simultaneously. In Nigeria, these models play out in such things as the choice of which Nigerian language should be learnt as L2 and which language should be used as mother tongue in school settings characterized by the presence of learners from different first languages. Given the close affiliation between language and culture, any language choices in such settings ultimately become a choice of which culture to advantage.
Challenges of Cultural Pluralism and Multilingualism in Nigerian Education
These are several and include Language Policy and Inequality, curriculum representation, the reality of resource constraints, the ever-present ethnic and religious sensitivities which may colour perception of educational decision taken, the problem of teacher supply and the availability of pedagogical materials. Let us now take up each of these in turn and discuss each albeit briefly
Language Policy and Inequality – One of the most difficult issues in Nigerian education concerns the language of instruction. While mother-tongue education is pedagogically desirable, implementing it across hundreds of languages is financially and administratively challenging.
Consequently, many minority languages remain excluded from instructional use, placing their speakers at educational disadvantage.
Curriculum Representation
Curriculum content in areas such as history and social studies often reflects dominant cultural narratives. National heroes, historical figures, and cultural references are frequently drawn from major ethnic groups, while minority cultures receive limited representation.
This may unintentionally create feelings of inferiority and exclusion among learners from minority backgrounds.
Resource Constraints
Developing multilingual curricula requires:
trained teachers;
instructional materials;
translation services;
orthographies for local languages;
and sustained financial investment.
Many developing countries struggle to provide these resources adequately.
Ethnic and Religious Sensitivities
Curriculum decisions involving religion, language, and culture are highly sensitive in Nigeria. Disagreements over religious instruction, civic education, and historical interpretation often reflect broader societal tensions.
Standardization Difficulties
Cultural diversity complicates efforts to standardize curriculum, assessment, and educational delivery nationwide. However, a basic truth that is worth asserting is that uniformity of curriculum offerings does not necessarily produce unity.
Teacher Preparedness
Many teachers lack adequate preparation in culturally responsive pedagogy. Without proper training, multicultural education may unintentionally reinforce stereotypes rather than promote inclusion.
Advantages of Cultural Pluralism and Multilingualism
Despite these challenges, cultural pluralism offers significant educational and societal benefits. These include the following:
Promotion of National Unity Through Inclusion
Inclusive curricula help learners feel recognized and valued within the national community, thereby strengthening social cohesion.
Preservation of Indigenous Cultures and Languages
Culturally responsive education contributes to the preservation of indigenous languages, histories, and knowledge systems.
Improved Learning Outcomes
Research consistently shows that children learn more effectively when instruction connects with their linguistic and cultural backgrounds.
Promotion of Tolerance and Intercultural Understanding
Exposure to multiple cultural perspectives helps reduce prejudice and promotes empathy, mutual respect, and peaceful coexistence. Specifically, the Urhobo adolescent who learns about Itsekiri culture is not only bound to become a more rounded but is also bound to display skills of empathy, acceptance and appreciation of fellow learners from other cultures.
Development of Critical Thinking
Multicultural education encourages learners to engage with diverse viewpoints and question assumptions critically.
Strengthening Learner Identity and Self-Esteem
Representation of diverse cultures in curriculum content helps learners develop confidence and pride in their heritage.
Disadvantages and Threats
These are several and include the following:
Risk of Ethnic Fragmentation
Excessive emphasis on cultural differences may deepen ethnic consciousness and weaken national identity.
Cultural Domination
Dominant groups may use education and language policy to reinforce their cultural influence over minority groups.
Linguistic Imperialism
Globalization and the increasing dominance of English create pressures that undermine indigenous languages and cultures. In the Nigerian case, the spread of Hausa language in the North of the country has become a threat to the survival of minority languages, some of which are now threatened with extinction of glottophagy. Without deliberate preservation efforts, minority languages may gradually disappear due to assimilation and globalization pressures.
Curriculum Overload
Attempting to represent all cultural groups adequately may lead to an overcrowded curriculum, but at the barest minimum, efforts must be made to ensure representativeness of the cultural practices of the various groups in society, whilst avoiding the dangers of political manipulation that may accompany such efforts as selection of Curriculum content may become politicized by powerful stakeholders with strong interests, such dangers being especially high in areas involving history, language, and religion.
The challenge of all the foregoing is how to develop school programs that capture the major educational benefits of multilingualism and cultural pluralism whilst minimizing the downsides. The next section examines their implications for curriculum development.
Implications for Curriculum Development in Nigeria
This concluding section commences on the basic premise that Curriculum development in Nigeria must balance two competing imperatives:
promoting national unity;
preserving cultural diversity.
Such a curriculum development should also be culturally responsive. A culturally responsive curriculum should:
represent diverse cultures fairly;
avoid stereotyping;
promote inclusive citizenship;
support multilingual education;
and foster intercultural dialogue.
There is also a need to move away from curricula that privilege only dominant narratives and instead create space for minority histories, local heroes, indigenous knowledge systems, and community experiences. The solutions proposed below are based on these foundational principles
Proposed Solutions and Recommendations
Promote Multilingual Education
Nigeria should strengthen mother-tongue instruction, especially at the early childhood and lower basic education levels.
Develop Inclusive Curricula
Curriculum content should reflect the histories, cultures, and experiences of diverse Nigerian communities.
Strengthen Teacher Training
Teachers should receive professional preparation in:
culturally responsive pedagogy;
multilingual education;
conflict-sensitive teaching;
and inclusive curriculum delivery.
Encourage Community Participation
Curriculum development should involve stakeholders from different cultural and linguistic groups as this is one sure way to ensure relevance and critical stakeholder engagement with school curricula.
Support Minority Languages
Government should invest in:
orthography development;
local language publishing;
translation;
teacher recruitment;
and indigenous language media.
All the suggested policy interventions above come under the scope of language engineering and planned language expansion. These are well discussed in Rubin and Jernudd (1971). At the Nigerian level, these issues mentioned above are well examined in Bamgbose, Akere, and Ihebuzor (1992) and in Ihebuzor and Junaidu (1994).
There is also the need to balance Diversity with National Cohesion whilst making efforts to integrate Indigenous Knowledge Systems in curricula offerings
Furthermore, educational policy should promote shared civic values while respecting cultural diversity. At the same time, and this is the challenging part, efforts must be made to ensure that curriculum content incorporates local knowledge, environmental practices, conflict-resolution traditions, and cultural heritage.
Finally, there is a need for regular and continuous curriculum review to ensure inclusiveness, relevance, and responsiveness of curricula to Nigeria’s evolving sociocultural realities.
Conclusion
Multilingualism and cultural pluralism remain central issues in curriculum development within Nigeria’s basic education system. While cultural diversity enriches education and strengthens democratic inclusion, it also presents significant challenges relating to language policy, equity, representation, and national cohesion.
Curriculum development in multicultural societies cannot be viewed as a neutral process. It reflects broader struggles over identity, power, ideology, and cultural representation. Consequently, educational policy must carefully balance the demands of national integration with the imperative of protecting minority cultures and languages.
For Nigeria, the challenge is not whether cultural pluralism should exist, but how it should be managed in ways that promote inclusion, educational equity, social cohesion, and sustainable national development. Finally, the way that Nigeria manages its cultural pluralism and multilingualism must be such that would advance her pursuit of SDGs 4 and 11.
Selected References
Bamgbose, A. (1992). Speaking in Tongues: Implications of Multilingualism for Language Policy in Nigeria.
Bamgbose, A, Akere F and Noel Ihebuzor (eds) (1992), Implementing the language provisions of the National Policy on Education, NERDC. Abuja, NERDC/FME
Barrow, R. (1976). Common Sense and the Curriculum. London: George Allen and Unwin.
Brent, A. (1978). Philosophical Foundations for the Curriculum. London: George Allen and Unwin.
Federal Government of Nigeria (1981). National Policy on Education. Lagos: NERDC Press
Fishman, J. (1993). “Ethnolinguistic Democracy: Varieties, Degrees and Limits.” Language International, 5(1), 11–14.
Ihebuzor, Noel& Ismail Junaidu (eds) (1994), Proceedings of the seminar on language survey planning, Lagos, NERDC
Phillipson, R. (1997). “Realities and Myths of Linguistic Imperialism.” Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development, 18(3), 238–248.
Rubin, J., & Jernudd, B. H. (1971). Can Language Be Planned? University of Hawaii Press.
Skutnabb-Kangas, T. (1988). “Multilingualism and the Education of Minority Children.” In Minority Education: From Shame to Struggle.
Young, C. (1979). The Politics of Cultural Pluralism. University of Wisconsin Press.
The 2025 Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) paints a sobering picture of global governance. Transparency International measured perceived public-sector corruption in 182 countries, and the global average fell to 42/100, the lowest in more than a decade. Most countries are struggling: 122 out of 180 scored below 50, showing widespread corruption challenges. Only five countries scored above 80, compared to 12 a decade ago. Denmark leads again with 89, while Somalia and South Sudan sit at the bottom with 9 each.
Key Highlights
Top performers: Denmark (89), Finland (88), Singapore (84), New Zealand (81), Norway (81).
Major democracies slipping: United States (64), Canada (75), United Kingdom (70), France (66), Sweden (80), New Zealand (81).
Lowest scorers: Venezuela (10), Somalia (9), South Sudan (9).
Global Trends
Democracy matters: Full democracies average 71, flawed democracies 47, authoritarian regimes 32.
Civic space is critical: Countries with open civic space average 68, while those with closed civic space average just 30.
Declines since 2012: 50 countries worsened, including Venezuela, Syria, Hungary, and South Sudan, where corruption has become systemic.
Consequences
The report links corruption to weakened institutions, poor public services, and rising inequality. It notes that restrictions on civic freedoms often coincide with declining CPI scores. For example, Georgia (50), Indonesia (34), Peru (30), and Tunisia (39) have seen governments limit NGO activity and intimidate journalists, worsening corruption risks.
Recommendations
Transparency International urges governments to:
Protect independent justice systems.
Ensure transparency in political finance and lobbying.
Safeguard civic space and media freedom.
Strengthen oversight of public spending.
Cooperate internationally to combat illicit financial flows.
One striking line from the report captures the urgency: “At a time of climate crisis, instability and polarisation, the world needs accountable leaders and independent institutions to protect the public interest more than ever – yet, too often, they are falling short.”
Would you like me to create a regional comparison table (e.g., Americas vs. Europe vs. Africa) so you can see how different parts of the world stack up against each other?
Truth is twisted, lies fall in to assorted lines, by hook and crook, mimicking straight lines, tangled lines tangle lives, tangled lives tangle minds, in vain we seek to untwist a tangled wreck,
the broom, overrun by yesteryear’s cobwebs has lost its power to sweep,
only witches and wild wizards, unable to find rest or sleep now hop around, crossing carpets to and fro, hopeless and hapless on its jagged ends!
1 It is sad when people and nations choose foolishly and then blame fate or the gods for the consequences of their choices. 2. Experience is the best teacher but Nigerians are resistant to its teaching. 3. Huge traces of masochism must be embedded in the DNA of large portions of our populace when it comes to making political choices. 4. One bitten, twice seduced, thrice perpetually confused! 5. Rational Choice Theory (RCT) can explain anything including the worst forms of irrationality and that is its core flaw!
Chuks Iloegbunam tells Sam Omatseye to cleanse his journalism
Some have called you foolish, dear Sam Omatseye. Others insist that you are plain stupid. There are those who hold you to be beneath contempt. Their howls of execration upon you are in reaction to your August 1, 2022 article entitled Obi-tuary (https://thenationonlineng.net/obi-tuary/). For me, however, you are a dear friend. Our friendship started in the 1980s at Newswatch magazine where both of us practiced journalism before you travelled to the United States for further studies. It continued upon your return and strengthened to the point that, sometimes, you get the producers of your TV Continental programme to connect me to field questions live. Besides, living in different states, we often chat by telephone. I demonstrated our amity again last May when I was in Nigeria’s commercial capital for the Lagos International Book Fair. I phoned you and, within the hour, you were at my stand where we spent quality time reminiscing about the good old days and prognosticating on the future of our dear fatherland.
Armed with this handle of friendship, I have just the one advice for you: Be careful. It is in elaboration of this counsel that I write all that you read hereon. Please look back to the time of the Nigeria-Biafra war of 1967 to 1970. You will find that, military or civilian, none of the political actors of that era is still in a position to fight elections today. The final curtain long fell for most of them. Of the lot that remains, some have become vegetables, or are propped up with a suffusion of drugs or would not find their way to the loo unless hired attendants or swearing relatives point it out. Together with the handful that is still blessed with something close to robust health, they have one thing in common. They are seated, restless or restive, in various existential departure halls, clutching fitfully at their boarding passes and waiting for that inevitable voice that cannot be disobeyed, to announce their flights into past tense.
In a broad sense, the departed leave their legacies, good, bad or ugly, for those standing in line and waiting their turns to also check out. What legacies, dear Sam, are you and I feverishly working day and night to leave for those coming in our wake? When you write an article that denigrates the Igbo nation of over 50 million people, and make nonsense of some of those things that mean the most to them, do you really believe that your disposition is justified by the pay and perquisites that accrue to you at Ahmed Bola Tinubu’s The Nation newspapers?
This is you: “The Biafran babblers are alive and well. They just swapped icons, rechristened the shrines and rewrote the rites. They left the prophet for a secular priest. They have had a switch of battle gear.” This clearly is a perfidious way of sentencing Ndigbo to the status of the bat that is neither bird nor mammal. Their fight for Biafra five decades ago was stopped. Their fight now for democratic integration impels you to call them babblers, i.e., people who are no more than endless talkers of nonsense. One would think that the bat sobriquet aptly becomes your Bola Ahmed Tinubu whose initials provide the BAT acrostic that he wears like a badge. I will sooner return to the BAT.
This, again, is your characterisation of the Igbo: “They can say they have a legitimate tribe and rhetoric. They may pretend to love Nigeria. They may claim to embrace INEC, cling to a political party no one in the police or DSS will harangue.”
Isn’t this the height of Igbophobia? We may go back in history. Before Tinubu, there were other Yoruba presidential candidates, including Chief Obafemi Awolowo, Chief M. K. O. Abiola, General Olusegun Obasanjo, Chief Gani Fawehinmi and Chief Olu Falae. None of these personages indexed their presidential ambition on stoking inter-tribal animosity between the Yoruba and the Igbo. As a matter of fact, Chief Philip Ezebuilo Umeadi, Igbo and one of the oldest Senior Advocates of Nigeria, was Papa Awolowo’s running mate in the 1979 presidential election.
Why does it make sense to you and to your principal that the only route to his vaulting presidential ambition must be one that sunders two ethnic groups that have since before the amalgamation been living together in amity, harmony and peace, two peoples that have always, in peace or in peril, lent each other a helping hand?
At the height of the Western Nigeria political crisis of the mid 1960s that pitted Chief Awolowo against Chief Samuel Ladoke Akintola, the former’s Action Group (AG) and Dr. M. I. Okpara’s National Convention of Nigerian Citizens (NCNC) entered into a coalition that birthed the United Progressives Grand Alliance (UPGA). We have it on Wole Soyinka’s authority – see page 73 of his autobiographical You Must Set Forth At Dawn (Bookcraft, Ibadan 2006) that Dr. Okpara lent the then incarcerated Awo a voice by dispatching Mazi Anyogu Elekwachi Ukonu and a complement of seasoned broadcasters that installed a transmitter right inside Awolowo’s Ibadan home.
Ndigbo were not a part of Awolowo’s treason trial and his imprisonment for ten years. Dr. Nnamdi Azikiwe even said that he was the one that insisted on Awolowo being imprisoned in Calabar, rather than in Northern Nigeria where the chief feared that poisoning could end his life.
It was not the Igbo that nullified Chief Abiola’s victory in the 1993 presidential election. Rather, Ndigbo were in the forefront of the NADECO (National Democratic Coalition) struggle against the gross injustice. At least a third of those that formed the NADECO were Igbo, according to a list in Battlelines: Adventures in Journalism and Politics, Chief Segun Osoba’s autobiography published in 2020 by Diamond Publications Limited, Lagos. They included Commodore Ebitu Ukiwe, the late Admiral Ndubuisi Kanu, Okwadike (Dr.) Chukwuemeka Ezeife, Prof Anya O. Anya, Chief Ralph Obioha, Chief Empire Kanu, Chief Michael Anyiam, Chief E. Duru, Chief Vincent Nwizugbo and Dr. Uma Eleazu.
NADECO had an international arm. In the United Kingdom, its meetings were held in the late Raph Uwechue’s Africa Books Limited offices in Hammersmith London. Chief Uwechue was Igbo. Dear Sam, I do not know exactly where you were at the time, and I concede that, among Nigerian politicians, there is something known as selective amnesia. If, therefore, your Tinubu, who lived in London for a portion of his exile, does not remember Uwechue’s role in NADECO, I am sure that none of General Alani Akinrinade, Professor Bolaji Akinyemi and Professor Sylvester Monye will ever forget. All the Igbo fighters for June 12 were not dissuaded by the fact that their struggle was to actualise the electoral mandate of Chief Abiola, a Yoruba politician. Apart from incarceration, harassment by security operatives and the alienation of exile, some of these men paid heavily in other ways for their commitment to cause of justice. Chief Bobo Nwosisi died in exile in London. Chief Obioha lost his bank, the First African Trust Bank Limited.
In the light of the above, readers would have to judge for themselves whether or not it is right for you, Sam, to say the following of Ndigbo: “They have transferred the temperament of their former master into the new. And they have not spared any incoherence, any lack of finesse, and threats and tantrums, any show of rabid, primitive cants, or any ululations. They have abused, cursed, thrown imprecations. They have hugged lies about their candidate. They have pelted lies about others. They have distorted material. Obi has turned out to be an excuse for even closet Biafrans to betray open emotions about Biafra without being accused of it.”
To be sure, your writing is not an aberrant occurrence. On July 17, 2022, an Adedamola Adetayo posted on the Internet an anti-Igbo diatribe in which he said, among other things that “They have a POLITICAL ZIONISM already in play. It is in the thing they deceptively call Obidients. That Movement is going to RALLY the Igbos of Lagos in a way that they haven’t ever been rallied. THEY ARE SET TO DETERMINE THE LEADERSHIP OF LAGOS. The priority is to remove Tinubu first. In future they will call the shot. This is what Peter Obi is all about. He has no plans for any Presidency. I can imagine that the ZIONISTS already have their IPOB/UGM all over the places in Lagos, in the Garrisons called Markets, under cover, masquerading as Igbo traders.”
Years before this ranting Adedamola Adetayo, John Femi Kusa, who had been a script editor at The Guardian in Lagos, also showed his claws. In March 2019, he published an article on the Internet with this sentence of a title: Okota: The Igbo Question, Jimi Agbaje, Afenifere And The Rest Of Us. In it, he claimed that, “The major problem, in my opinion, is the Igbo penchant to wish to take over another person’s land…Lagos was either a colony or a part of Western Nigeria. But because of the generosity of Yorubas and the foresight of their forefathers which made this region the star region in West Africa, the Igbos would like the Yorubaman to believe that LAGOS IS NO MAN’S LAND. Can anyone say that of Benin without eating his pounded yam as raw yam?”
Dear Sam, your Obi-tuary piece is as incendiary as the hateful views of Kusa and Adetayo. Kusa, now well into his 70s will not physically go feeding the Igbo raw yam. But all the vitriol you guys have been pushing against the Igbo is the stuff that leads the M. C. Oluomos into mindless violence and murder and arson and brigandage. You pen pushers of evil are the ones that egg on the rabble into wielding guns and cudgels and massacring innocent people for transient political offices. Is it right to promote this permittivity simply so that Tinubu will attain his wild goose chase of the presidential crown?
Kusa schooled at the University of Nigeria, Nsukka, earning a degree in Mass Communication. All through his years in the Igbo country, not once was he molested or denied his citizenship on account of his origin. Did his welcome at Nsukka lead him into believing that the town was a part of the Yoruba country? According to Facebook, the acerbic Adetayo guy schooled at the Nnamdi Azikiwe University, Awka, and earned a degree there without abuse, let or hindrance. Maybe it got fixed inside his brain that Awka is an extension of Lagos, or that Azikiwe after whom the institution was named was his progenitor.
If there are Ndigbo who say that Lagos is a no man’s land, can one Igbo person be put up who simply seized a piece of land in the metropolis and converted it to his use? If Nigerians, including Tinubu’s daughters, who have being buying up choice properties in New England, United States, can own houses in Europe, North America, the Middle East and elsewhere, why must it rankle that Ndigbo own property in Lagos? Why must ownership of landed property in one’s own country lead to calumniation and physical harm? Is it not too steep a price to pay in order that Tinubu should become Nigeria’s president?
The Igbo were not responsible for the recent bloody massacre of congregants inside the St Francis Catholic Church in Owo, Ondo State. The Igbo are not among those sentenced to death by hanging for the murder of Afenifere leader Chief Reuben Fasanranti’s daughter. The herdsmen marauding, pillaging and plundering Yoruba land, looting, raping women, destroying farmlands and spreading death and destruction are not Igbo. The Igbo man did not kill a soul. He did not contest the governorship of Lagos. He hasn’t ever claimed ownership of Iga Idungaran. The Igbo always lived in peace with the Yoruba – until Tinubu surfaced with his divisive politics. Are the vociferous Igbo supporters of Tinubu no longer of the ethnic group because of their partisan predilection?
Sam, informed readers of your articles are aware that your allusions to classical Anglo-Saxon, Greek and Roman mythologies and literary divergences are no more than an egregious attempt at appropriating the intellectual centre circle. Otherwise, you would appreciate the importance of adding depth to your fulminations. Any owner of a book of quotable quotes or a glossary of literary terms can fill their verbiage with citations. But that is no scholarship, my friend. Look at you: “Obi is like Zik, Kanu like Ojukwu. One is a flair, the other a flare.” Yet, it doesn’t strike you as reasonable to accord some of Zik’s aptitude to Peter Obi, a man who earned an honours degree in Philosophy from Nigeria’s premier indigenous university that was built by the great Zik of Africa. And Ojukwu is no more than a flare. By impugning him with combustibility, you forget that in January 1967, Ojukwu went to Aburi, Ghana, not with an incendiary device, but with the sole purpose of putting out the smoldering fire that was threatening to become a national conflagration. You forget that it was not Ojukwu but those that reneged on the Aburi Accord that tossed a lit match in an ocean of gasoline.
I agree with those that have invested you with the coronet of a seasoned journalist. Except that your coronation disdains the fact that your brand of perceptive journalism is only seasonal. That explains why it bothers you that “Obi hops from church to church,” but means absolutely nothing to you that as Dele Sobowale reported in the Sunday Vanguard of July 10, 2022 “…Bola Tinubu has charged the Supreme Council for Sharia in the country to create a department of political affairs to create political awareness among the faithful towards producing a Muslim President in 2023.” Neither do you care a hoot that, as Dr. Sobowale added in the same article “Tinubu has followed up that injunction to the Supreme Council for Sharia, by making secret pledges to expand the reach of Sharia to more Southern States if elected.”
Rather, you call Peter Obi a hypocrite. But Mr. Obi gave his date of birth, the name of his parents, the town he hails from, the schools he attended and the businesses he is into. All were found to be correct. Not being at all interested in the truth, you threw Mr. Obi’s data out of the window because you must be seen to be frantically propagating a character of disputed age, of unknown pedigree, unascertained genealogy, unsubstantiated name, uncorroborated curriculum vitae, and unverified academic diplomas. You shout from the rooftops that Peter Obi is not fit to govern. But you posit as fit for the presidential palace a specimen of incontinence, tremulous lower extremities, slurred speech, unsteady gait and memory lapses. You cannot be serious, my friend.
Of course, it is your entitlement to advertise even ordure if that captures your fancy, but you may not carry on as though your readers are imbecilic. By raising the Biafran bogey, your intention was clearly to create doubt and apprehension. But your gambit only registered a calamitous failure. Jonathan was President of this country. It didn’t obliterate Niger Delta agitation. Buhari is president of this country; those of his people campaigning for the Islamic State haven’t thrust their swords in their scabbards. You have a fondness for excoriating Nnamdi Kanu. Excellent! Except that your seasonal flair for journalism has never prompted you into examining the Sunday Igboho phenomenon. You make yourself a laughing stock by encapsulating in ethnic strictures the pan-Nigerian Peter Obi Movement that is youth led. You reckon not one bit that the youths that are sick and tired of the sanguinary dreariness and aridity of your principal’s vanishing epoch.
Nonetheless, you cannot contest the truism that, in the last analysis, everything goes and turns round. All metals are bound for the anvil. We are here today – those, like Peter Obi and his equally competent and credible running mate, Yusuf Datti Baba-Ahmed, that wish to place a new heart in the Nigerian nation; and others like your principal and his paid battalions of blinkered acolytes that, as Pa Ayo Adebanjo finely put it, are only interested in continuing and escalating the rot they inflicted on hapless Nigerians in 2015. Whatever tomorrow brings, you must continue to ruminate over the legacy you will leave for coming generations. Every one of us will have their entrance and their exit, it being a settled fact that obituary’s certitude rings true for all comers, not just for Peter Obi as you wantonly asserted.
Chuks Iloegbunam is the author of the upcoming book on Mr. Peter Obi entitled The Promise of a New Era.
Today’s first reading says it all for me. There is nothing that God cannot do. Nothing! I survey our current tragedies and aridities, I contemplate the endless twisting and slippery road before us, I examine the wasteland before us, an avoidable wasteland caused by greed, incompetence, lack of vision, emotional aridity and lack of compassion…..yes, I see the suffering these impose on us – the suffocating climate of helplessness and rampaging despondency….and many more negative manifestations of these sad times….and I remember the qualities of our God, the qualities of our God who renews and who converts deserts to greens, who levels mountains and I tell myself, this current mess, these years of mess, these years of hunchback misery, this insecurity, this hopelessness, this bumbling inefficiency, this reign and triumph of arrogance and ignorance… yes, ALL THESE MUST PASS. Join me in a loud MARANATHA!
The person who calls his/her child Nkemdirim is not asking for too much! The person is simply asking God to confirm and sustain his gift to him or her. He or she is also asking God to imbue that gift with utility, distinctiveness, a sense of identity, permanence and sustainability. Nkemdirim is also a prayer that the gift remains with us whatever may be the vicissitudes of life!
People advance and progress when they grow, solidify and edify what is theirs. People advance when they build on their positive values and assets. Peoples and nations advance recognizing the value of what is theirs and not by uncritical self abandonment nor by group rejection nor through the adoption of the structures that belong to others. You cannot be an Ogaranya with someone else’s wealth or structure. Charity and beauty, they say, start from home. “Eji eshi uyo mara mma fuma ama” the Owerri person would say, and correctly too! We approach others with more confidence and with a greater sense of security when invested and vested in our uniqueness, our USP, if you like. These constitute our distinctiveness. In such situations, our base is firm, our unit flags, our symbols and our totems are visible, unique, vibrant and distinctive.
These things give us identity. A family, a village, a town, a clan…indeed, any structure without identity is lost and will be absorbed by others in a way that degrades it and ultimately wipes it off from any serious reckoning.
As in life, so also in other spheres of life, including associating with others in politics. Which political structure is ours? Just asking! Nkemdirim.
The successful inauguration ceremonies yesterday in the USA after weeks of turbulence and mayhem prompts these quick reflections on the importance of institutions in governance, alternation and social stability. They extend my earlier musings on institutions and are essentially intended to make the case for all and sundry to abandon short term expediency driven thinking and support citizen efforts and coalitions focused on institution building and strengthening. Sustainable development depends on strong institutions. SDG 16 clearly makes this case. Institutions are as strong as the degree of immersion of its operators in their key norms and tenets, the socialization of these operators and the larger society into accepting the utility of such norms, the interlocks and interpenetration of their supporting networks and the quality of the enculturation of a critical mass of society of its key ethos and beliefs. The absence of all these explains the sad and repeated and repeating cases of institutional failures in Nigeria. The presence of these explains why Trump could not get the army to violate its oath. Poorly locked down norms and weak norm enculturation among a critical mass of stakeholders also can explain the vagaries, abuses and somersaults in some countries with huge GDPs but febrile and feeble institutions.
Recent events in our world are making us painfully aware that the institutions on which our societies are built are under threat. On-going efforts in a number of countries around the world, including attempts at muzzling the press, gimmicks by a president to delegitimize the outcome of an electoral process, the hijacking of parliaments in some countries, the use of deadly force against peaceful demonstrators and efforts at voter suppression all point to the dangers that society and institutions are increasingly facing in our modern world.
Furthermore, the rising incidences of insecurity, poverty, hunger, injustice, systemic racism and gender-based violence, just to mention a few, are not fortuitous, but are rather signals that the institutions that are or were meant to guard against such are no longer functioning at their optimal levels. Ditto for failures in public procurement, declining standards in the regularity and quality of urban basic services and in collapsing municipal functions.
The institutions that are meant to ensure that these services are provided or which were designed to protect our freedoms are now either becoming increasingly moribund or experiencing severe existential threats or are being exposed to severe bashing and or subversion, some subtle and some, frontal, brutal and unrelenting.
The phenomenon of institutional bashing appears to be spreading all over the world from Asia, North America, South America, Europe to Africa, and if current happenings in God’s own country are anything to go by, would be seem to be gathering momentum and exercising a strong fascination for an increasing group of persons, converts and democracy iconoclasts.
The aberrations mentioned above produce effects that lead to democratic backsliding, a backsliding that could then set off a vicious cycle of institutional weakening with deleterious impacts on a broad range of other institutions and this with major multiplier effects and compounded negative externalities and a number of social malaises.
If these malaises can be blamed on weakening of institutions, what then are institutions? These non-random musings are prompted by a genuine desire to explore the concept of institutions, to unearth its meaning and the key assumptions that populate its vast and ever-expanding literature.
These ramblings are structured thus – they start with an examination of the meaning of institutions and then move on to a consideration of the functions of institutions in society. From here, focus then shifts to threats to institutions and the ramblings end on what responsible citizens can do to check the attack on institutions.
One needs to acknowledge from the outset that the literature in the area poses major challenges and which unless navigated with caution could represent conceptual landmines that stand in the way of shared understanding. Taking a leaf from North, all scholars in the field talk of rules of the game but most of the literature is quite fuzzy when it comes to giving concrete examples. For some, family is an institution, for some others, marriage. For some, Governance is an institution, for some others the constitution and the system of election are. People like me in search of clarity could thus be wrong-footed in this maze of definitional unclarity and inadequacies.
Perhaps scholars need to come together to speedily address and resolve this unclarity. In such an effort, the definitions of sociologists, economists and administrators must be assisted to find common grounds both in content and in examples that they provide.
For now, one can work with the following definition – Institutions are the formal and informal rules and norms that organize social, political and economic relations (North, 1990). Institutions are ‘the underlying rules of the game’. They are not the same as organizations.
Organizations are ‘groups of individuals bound by a common purpose’. Organizations are shaped by institutions and, in turn, influence how institutions change. Some social scientists view organizations as the material expressions of institutions. Some see social groups such as government bodies, tribes and families as institutions. Some identify ‘primary’ or ‘meta’ institutions to be the family, government, economy, education and religion. North, 1990: 3, 5; Harper et al., 2012: 15.
Key features of institutions are the following – They are brought to life by people and organizations (North, 1990; Leftwich & Sen, 2010). They provide a relatively predictable structure for everyday social, economic and political life. Institutions shape people’s incentives (or calculations of returns from their actions) and behavior. They establish a predictable, though not necessarily efficient or uncontested structure for human interaction (North, 1990: 6). Some argue institutions shape but do not necessarily always determine behavior (Leftwich & Sen, 2010: 9). They lead to enduring patterns of behavior over time but they also change. Institutions are constantly being reformed through people’s actions (Giddens, 1984). Institutional change structures the way societies evolve (North, 1990: 3). However, institutionalized behaviors can be hard to change. They produce positive or negative development outcomes. This depends on the kinds of relations and behaviors that institutions enable, and the outcomes for the enjoyment of rights and allocation of resources in society (Leftwich & Sen, 2010). Institutions are both formal and informal. Formal institutions include the written constitution, laws, policies, rights and regulations enforced by official authorities. Informal institutions are (the usually unwritten) social norms, customs or traditions that shape thought and behaviour (Leftwich & Sen, 2010; Berman, 2013). Development practitioners have tended to prioritise formal institutions, viewing informal ones as separate and often detrimental to development outcomes (Unsworth, 2010).
In practice, formal and informal rules and norms can be complementary, competing or overlapping (Jütting et al., 2007: 36; Leftwich & Sen, 2010: 17). Whether they are relatively more strong/weak or inclusive/discriminatory is likely to depend on context (Unsworth, 2010). In some cases, informal institutions undermine formal ones; in others they substitute for them (Leftwich & Sen, 2010: 17; Jütting et al., 2007: 35-36). Informal social norms often shape the design and implementation of formal state institutions (Migdal, 2001; Jütting et al., 2007: 7).
Let us note the following – Institutions should not be mistaken with buildings or physical structures. They rather refer to a set or series of rules, practices and procedures which govern the smooth functioning of societies. Institutions involve rules and norms, but some of these rules and norms are almost imperceptible and rely on a series of layered conventions and assumptions to maintain order and harmony in society. Concerning the link between development interventions and institutions, DFID argues that development interventions are more likely to succeed if they promote improvements at the wider level of institutions. (Without institutional reform, for instance, poverty alleviation programmes can fail – a basic truth that explains the glaring failures and indeed the poverty of most of poverty alleviation programmes in a number of third world economies).
Family, marriage, government, banks, religious organizations, social clubs, parliaments, schools etc are all institutions. One can argue a certain biologism when examining institutions and their functions. Marriage as institution, for instance, functions to ensure social stability, reproduction and production. Places of religious worship function as defenders of morals, morality and social ethics.
The age grade system in Igbo society is an example of a social institution that is society specific. The KKK is not an institution but an organization but the rules and norms of white supremacy and racial privilege on which it is built and sustained are aspects of an institution of systemic racism.
The police and the criminal justice system are institutions designed to save society from anarchy, the rule of brute force and to ensure the protection of the weak.
Banks, investment houses, the stock exchange are all institutions meant to sustain economic growth by ensuring greater predictability and protection in financial dealings and flows. The civil society, the industrial unions, the town associations are all institutions all designed to permit greater citizenship participation and ownership.
In the domains of governance and politics, one comes across a vast array of institutions, each with a number of functions and some with overlapping functions, rules and norms Some scholars have isolated three sets of political institutions – these are the State, Rule of law and institutions that make for accountability.
The state is defined as a structure that holds the monopoly of legitimate violence. In this view, the state represents a concentration of power and capacity for enforcement. The modern state is impersonal, best run on merit and talent and by an efficient bureaucracy. Rule of law represents an institution that allows for the power of the state to be held in check. According to Fukuyama, the rule of law is a constraint on the executive and embedded in a separate independent judiciary.
The last in the tripod of political institutions are accountability mechanisms that cover issues such as procedural and moral accountability and responsibility.
We can also say in a wider conception of institution that the judiciary is an institution, so are the legislature and the executive and these three need to be kept separate in good governance is to survive and thrive. The press is an institution, sometimes even called the fourth estate of the realm and is also vital for good governance.
These four institutions must be kept separate to preserve societies from the menace of tyrants and dictators.
Institutions thus have functions in society – They operate to safeguard society. They make for normalcy and for ensuring that all keep within agreed and often unwritten norms They define expectations, responsibility and establish accountability based on agreed division of labor. Institutions are interlinked such that one weakness in one can lead to weakness in another and in several others. While some are society specific, some have rules and norms that are universal.
Institutional development is a complex process which draws from and build on local realities. The dynamics of institutional change are complex. Creating institutional change is a slow difficult process and some times involves changes in cultural beliefs, norms and assumptions. Such change can often meet with resistance. For this reason, it is important from the outset to establish the development outcomes of any proposed institutional change.
It is critical to distinguish between the organizational changes and the changes in the wider institutional framework needed to achieve these outcomes. Organizational problems are usually visible and tangible while those to do with institutions may be invisible but determine how people operate in society.
Institutional interventions (those that deal with institutional problems) can be divided into two areas: policy reform and improved service delivery. Organizational interventions, on the other hand, can be at three levels: structure, systems and human resources
Successful interventions (be these at organizational or institutional levels) require the active participation of all the stakeholders in diagnosing the problems to be tackled and deciding on the actions to be taken. They also require the following i) Accessing important sources of information and research material to inform both the institutional and organizational appraisal ii) Identifying the key people in implementing the intervention along with their roles and responsibilities. iii) Designing an effective strategy and programme for implementation of the planned intervention, and taking action if a programme becomes stalled and iv) Putting effective evaluation and monitoring systems in place so that there will be clear evidence that the goals of the intervention have been achieved.
Threats to the solidity to democracy that these three institutions contribute to begin to surface when topics like benevolent dictatorships, authoritarian modernizers and well-meaning authoritarianism are allowed to creep into the public discourse.
Tyrants are very fond of such notions and they encourage the uptake of discourse that promote and justify them to creep and seep into the public domain. Things like benevolent dictatorships and authoritarian modernization are unsustainable and their presence in public discourse should be seen as red flags.
For one thing, models inspired by such notions eventually build the cult of the strong man, and such a strong man is usually insensitive to and non-receptive of feedback.
Such developments are red flags, and once these begin to appear, institutions come under threat – both in terms of solidity and stability
Essentially such institutions are concerned with making power responsible and ensure that decisions taken by the executive serve the common good
The rule of law therefore represents norms of justice that are applicable to all without exception
Standard orthodoxy holds that social progress depends on the solidity of institutional arrangements
Some development theorists have argued that development is impossible in the absence of strong institutions, that institutions safeguard development and make them sustainable.
Some others have also argued that you do not really need institutions for development to occur, that institutions involve too many transaction costs and that development, any way, brings institutions in its wake. The questions that then emerges is a chicken and egg one – which came before the other. A related and often ignored question is that of the trade-offs involved.
Each one of these two possible views implies a view of development – both in terms of its social drivers, the role of people participation in it and the whole question of sustainability. Though views on development may vary and clash, there is a strong consensus among development practitioners on the role of good governance in promoting development.
Such an emerging consensus is now leading scholars and practitioners to devote more and more time to understanding those institutions that combine to enable societies to have all the benefits of good governance.
Good governance is about public service that is efficient, effective, responsive, transparent, accountable, consensus oriented and participatory. These qualities of Governance all add up to contribute to society’s social capital. Social capital forms the structure on which most other capitals – economic, financial, knowledge, intellectual, legal – are built
Tyrants and dictators whether of the left or from the right are the greatest threats to the stability of social institutions, and thus to good governance and ultimately to the sanctity and the rights of the citizen. A system of checks, balances and rules are usually put in place to keep such institutions functional and thriving. Dictators and tyrants do their best to undermine the functioning of such institutions.
They try to do this by undermining and weakening institutions through a number of egregious acts that threaten and eventually undermine and subvert such institutions. They do or try to do through several strategies viz • They de-legitimize such institutions. They trivialize such institutions • They underfund such institutions. • They influence and corrupt the leadership of key societal institutions
Other antics include the attack and demoralization of the judiciary and legislative institutions. • parliament is bought over with generous gifts and its members are progressively seduced to soil their hands and to part company with honour, decency and professional rectitude through the instrumentality of generous gifts. • anti-corruption agencies are converted to instruments for personal vengeance and attacks against opponents. • the corruption of anti-corruption agencies is a major feature of efforts to weaken and demolish institutions
Other institution bashing moves include the following: • some Institutions become co-opted as willing hatchet structures and weapons whose primary assignments and ultimate deliverable are the discrediting and eventual drowning of existing institutions. • The police and other law enforcement agencies are perverted. • organs of government, especially the judiciary are bought over and soon begin to deliver judgements that put their whole integrity and the credibility of their judgments in doubt.
As these processes are unleashed on an indifferent or tolerant society, one begins to notice that the strong man who arrived as a liberator and reformer is gradually morphing into a tyrant. Most times, this strong man/woman rides in on a wave of public disenchantment with existing social stasis which he exploits to wrest extra-judiciary and legislative powers. He or she demonizes the leaders of institutions that they cannot buy over. Suddenly elections are decided by the courts and judges appointed by the strongman/woman. Soon justices, judges and magistrates court the friendship of their strong man/woman who eventually curtails their powers and tenure according to his/her whims and pleasures
The strong man/woman unleashes a campaign of harassment and terror against such any institutional leadership that is bold enough to speak out. The strong meddles, pesters and slowly and subtly hijacks the organs and institutions of the state and converts these to attack dogs, rottweilers and agents of terror
He perverts, through a series of accretions, the ethos and functioning of some institutions. The long-term objective is the hijack and personalization of Institutions of the state.
New structures with hazily defined functions but limited accountability to the public are soon spawned. Constitutional provisions are ignored or spurned. A gradual attack on civil liberties with the complicity of an emasculated and perverted judiciary soon commences and pucks up speed. Civil society and the press are muzzled. Laws limiting freedom of expression and are rushed through to legitimize new and emergent forms of illegitimacy
Soon a new norm, corrupt in intention, warped in its formulation and odious in its outcomes starts being installed. Decency is dismantled progressively and existing institutions soon begin to lose their internal autonomy. The structure and composition of some state institutions are soon changed by such usurpers. When institutions are forced and rushed through such changes, they begin to lose their credibility in the eyes of the public. They also become weaker. Weak institutions allow for further weakening and social abuse.
Because institutions are organically linked and exist in some form of hierarchy, a weakening of one institution transmits some weakening to other institutions engaged in similar civic protection functions. For example, a weak legislative invariably leads to a weak judiciary, which in turn leads to a weakening of institution concerned with the protection of civil liberties
One of the greatest threats to the autonomy of institutions is their personalization by such power usurpers. Features of such usurpation and perversion/hijack of functions of public institutions is their use to settle personal scores and not for the service of the people. Sadly, such selfish exploitation of the functions of public institutions is accompanied by the acquiescence of the public in the loss and suspension of personal liberties. The justification and rationalization of this loss of personal freedoms is usually done by invoking the idea that this is being done for a superior public good.
Strong ambitious individuals are a threat to institutions of state. Insensitive individuals are the worst enemies of institution. Dictators hate institutions. Institution bashers hate institutions. Tyrants work to weaken institutions. Such persons can achieve these feats because of the lethargy and indifference of the public.
The dismantling of institutions thrives in a situation where the public is lethargic Institution dismantling thrives in an atmosphere of stakeholder and citizen indifference. Africa has had more than its fair share of such institution dismantlers. In this regard, a reading of Michela Wrong’s “In the footsteps of Mr. Kurtz; living on the brink of disaster in Mobutu’s Congo” is most revealing and instructive. Mobutu was the institution dismantler par excellence.
Often times, such dismantling is done in slow imperceptible stages such that by the time the public wakes up, a lot has been lost and is difficult to pull back. Such usurpers usually sell themselves to a gullible public as messiahs who have come to redeem society and restore its sanity. A cult of the person is carefully cultivated such the strong individual is easily allowed to usurp functions and roles that are not his/hers.
Selfish individualism and an absence of social cohesion breeds anomie and criticism which then encourage institution dismantles of rashness and further knavery. Civic timorousness encourages usurper temerity. Fela said it well -“I no wan die”, “Papa dey for house”, “I wan enjoy” – are all attitudes which lead to societal indifference.
Responsible citizens must all unite to resist the dismantling of institutions of democracy. They must overcome divisions that usurpers try to exploit. The common divisions that such usurpers appeal to are those of Creed and Breed. Such usurpers also appeal to Greed existing in society to recruit an army of followers who they use to advance their selfish and socially destructive purposes.
Andrew Marantz in an article in the New Yorker of November 16 2020 identifies the key risks that institutional violators and power grabbers who I prefer to describe as progressive institutional rapists pose to democracy. Marantz goes on to describe how the actions of such persons can lead to the norms and rules of institutions growing weaker over years or decades without people noticing. He also points out that there often are decisive moments of contestation and confusion that such violators and authoritarian power grabbers stoke and exploit to steal power and damage institutions. Maurice Latey, in Tyranny, A Study in the Abuse of Power makes similar observations.
When institutions are destroyed or perverted, the destroyer becomes stronger and the larger society gets weaker following the rapid loss of freedoms – society must therefore come together to challenge, resist and pushback. Your personal freedoms and liberties depend on such resistance as these institutions are the bulwarks for the defense of personal freedoms.
Options for resisting such erosions of the protective power of institutions include strategic non-violent activism and civil resistance for security, rights and access. John Lewis’ concept of good trouble should inspire all civil rights defenders here, whether these be individuals protesting the perversion and conversion of agencies and institutions for citizen protection to instruments of citizen persecution, extortion and exploitation. Good trouble is a good way to protect those institutions that were meant to protect us from abuse. Silence is not an option.
Acquiescing in the dismantling of such protective institutions therefore amounts to selling your liberty and freedom. Rights and freedoms must be defended
Noel Ihebuzor 18/11/2020
Useful sources on institutions DFID Guidelines on Promoting Institutional and Organisational Development (2003a) provide an overview of institutions and institutional change. Leftwich and Sen (2010) define institutions and their policy implications for donors. Giddens (1984) explores the role of structure and institutions in society. Harper et al. (2012) explain different understandings of institutions. Helmke and Levitsky (2004) summarise the literature on informal institutions. Jütting et al. (2007) summarise key issues on informal institutions and development. North (1990) provides a seminal definition of institutions and institutional change. Unsworth (2010) explores the interaction of formal and informal institutions. – « Inclusive institutions on the development agenda, How institutions shape development outcomes »